No, you’re not seeing things: there is a new Wayfarer album and it is being featured in our non-metal column.  Naturally, this is going to lead to a lot of hand-wringing and pearl-clutching; Colorado’s premier Western-themed black metal act has been one of the darlings of the modern metal scene ever since they fully embraced the Wild West inspiration and let loose.  How could they dare create anything outside of their very particular wheelhouse?  Well, astute listeners might recall that Wayfarer have earned the ability to be trusted on a creative level, and Riders of the Setting Sun might actually be the clearest and most logical next step in their musical journey.

So…what is Riders of the Setting Sun, if not a Western-tinged folky black metal album?  New Americana, according to the band themselves.  What’s that?  It’s a little bit of everything you want it to be: folk, country, blues, rock and roll, post-punk…everything except black metal, that is.  No harsh vocals, no blast beats, no crunchy riffs, just groove, attitude and a melancholy bleakness that’s neither unexpected nor out of place, considering how jarring the rest of the changes must be to longtime fans. 

And while these changes are a lot to take in at first, at its core it’s still the same Wayfarer it has been for a long time: Isaac Faulk still sits behind the kit, although his usual battery is much more subtle and nuanced; we still have guitar and vocals from Shane McCarthy, but his roar is tamed down to a crooning baritone that lopes along the songs’ length; James Hansen’s bass is honestly more prominent than ever, given all the post-punk influence on Riders; and Joe Strong-Truscelli still lays down excellent lead work, only now it’s more atmospheric and bluesy than metallic.  The bones of a Wayfarer album are still here, and anyone who listens to Riders with an open mind will see that this is still the same band, just dialed in a little differently. 

And speaking of dialed in, there are even more firsts that come with Riders: the first time Wayfarer has worked with producer Ben Chisholm (notable for his work with Chelsea Wolfe) and engineers James Barone of Beach House and Iver Sandoy of the one and only Enslaved.  That’s…uh, quite an eclectic team we’ve got here, but it works incredibly well to bring a brand new vision to life for Wayfarer.

So well, in fact, that opener “The Dusklands” immediately made me feel right at home.  It’s a classic Wayfarer song, from the spur jingles that kick things off all the way through the breakdown that closes things out.  McCarthy’s voice isn’t exactly in-your-face, but his delivery is forceful even if he’s not bellowing or retching, Strong-Truscelli’s guitars lay down the same twangy leads that make songs pop, and Isaac Faulk still provides a litany of examples of why he is in an elite class amongst drummers in any genre.  Yes, this is a different Wayfarer, but it’s still Wayfarer, and these changes had me genuinely excited to see what else the quartet can do. 

Well, it turns out, a lot!  Isaac Faulk’s piano on “Black Roses and Early Graves” adds some saccharine sentimentality while still grounding the dirge in its Western roots, and that’s to say nothing of the drum clinic he puts on.  The vocal effects layered on McCarthy on “Casey’s Last Ride” give a vintage feel to the ballad, and Hansen’s bass lurches and lumbers in tandem with Faulk’s drums, but also lends an 80’s-esque melodic feel that leans into the post-punk really tastily.  Strong-Truscelli’s downright rock and roll solo that closes the epic “Hollow Hearts on the Trail to Eden” is as good as anything the band has ever done.  Any of these could be cited as reasons why we should have faith and trust in Wayfarer to do the job well.  Riders of the Setting Sun is a master stroke in the band capitalizing fully on what makes them unique and taking a huge risk in pursuit of their art and their vision.  It’s a goddamn home run.

One thing that I always find myself saying every time a new Wayfarer album comes out is that somehow they manage to top themselves, every single time; every new Wayfarer album is the best Wayfarer album.  Is that still true when it’s so hard to run an A to B comparison between releases?  Perhaps, but at this point I also think I’m done trying to compare Wayfarer to themselves.  They are truly one of those rare bands that can consistently reinvent themselves and simultaneously grow, evolve and still sound exactly like themselves.  That is a rare gift, and so is Riders of the Setting Sun.

— Ian


Riders of the Setting Sun is available now on Vesperian.  For more information on Wayfarer, visit their Facebook page.

Leave a Reply

Trending